unusual audio

ok ya novelty genre works

sure

yeah, i should add editing genre & lang now that graveyard stuff is a thing. "novelty" genre would potentially cover this then?

i mean for stuff thats already on the leaderboard yeah agree, hence why earlier i said its useless before graved sets are addable - also this was also meant to cover stuff thats not tagged as novelty on the main site (both my examples doesn't have novelty tag)

though if proposing for editing tags is easier to implement then i'm ok on just waiting for that to be implemented instead of having descriptors for these kind of stuff

> im ambivalent as to how useful this is but also inis style is a tag so maybe im overthinking it

iNiS style is a tag for an existing mapping style and is not represented in either the legacy identifications (genre and language) so it makes sense for it to be a descriptor

This proposal gets way less convincing even after the changes… feels like someone could just use the novelty language genre to look up charts of maps like these. Only thing is missing is the ability to propose map edits for genre and language which I suppose can be easily added in the future

reharmonized speech bits stuff doesn't count ideally since thats still kind of a song

thats it thx i'm overthinking it for no reason

also more examples:
/s/490101 /s/729089

okay awesome changed to a yes bc if the map exists in the listing anyway it ought 2 be properly tagged

im ambivalent as to how useful this is but also inis style is a tag so maybe im overthinking it
current description is a bit wordy and weird; i'd go w something like "Uses a non-song backing audio track."

hopefully this is good enough

this is still nowhere near the standard i'd expect to see for proposals, take a look at the way current descriptor descriptions are formatted for reference

just used novelty because ranked use novelty tag for smth similar ish

idk a better name for this tbh suggest smth better i'll take anything

this isn't really the definition of novelty though

also this would be a useless idea if graved maps indexing is not a thing imo but now you can put in graved maps soooo

did something

good initiative but obviously needs way way better than this. i'd recommend drafting something more full before opening a proposal in the future

don't know how to describe this in a good and not bullshit way but it's for stuff like this wwwwwwwwwwwww - wwwwwwwwwwww (ID => 696435)

also not sure if parent tag should be meta information