custom song
pending| Name | custom song |
| Description | Maps a song which was originally made for the map, or was made with the intention of being mapped for an event such as a mapping contest which the map participated in. |
| Parent descriptor | meta information |
| Proposer | TotallyWaffles |
| Type | new |
| Creation date | 2024-07-08 11:10:51 |
| Last updated | 2024-07-09 12:42:59 |
| Proposals can be approved when it receives 20 votes and has >=65% positive votes. Approvals can only happen after a minimum of 5 days. |
Vote
72.73% voted positivelyyes (16): Sanch-KK, Liyac, Emiya Nikita, TotallyWaffles, weed machine, squirrelpascals, [[[[[[, unwound, Kimitakari, Fsjallink, HAUNTE, doops, KnightC0re, E4pi4mak, Leviathan, OneDarthYear
no (3): aspen, rHO, moonpoint
hold (3): Constantine, Erikillo, milr_
Comments (11)
I disagree. We already have feautred artist as a descriptor and this is the same category of thing as that, and a list doesnt allow the sorting options a descriptor allows like highest rating, year, etc.
feels more fitting for a list
then it isnt a custom song since the song wasnt meant for that map
what if u map an osu original that has already been mapped or something of the sort
changed the description to include mapping contest original songs
- a map of an osu original song that isnt the map the song was made for wouldnt count for this descriptor. I dont see why this possibility would make this descriptor invalid.
- Another descriptor for osu originals would be a good idea, but that doesnt change the validity of this descriptor
- I could change it to commissioned track as that is what most (if not all) custom songs currently are, but there are possibilites fr a custom song not to be commisioned, such as the beatmap creator making the song
rename this to commisioned tracks?
yea deca's idea makes sense, splitting to osu! original for officially licenced and something like community original for the rest
using "custom" kinda limits the descriptor for tournaments when it could be used for mapping contests (like twin trials for example)
seems like this could just be split into two descriptors then: "osu! original" and "custom song" (or if other people have better ideas for names) perhaps for fully original mapsets vs just "song made for osu!"
i dont agree with this cause theres ranked maps of originals originating from different modes
self explanatory