i feel like this is one of those maps i'm going to appreciate more in the future but i still recognize the stupid amount of effort i put into trying to make this work
I feel like the concept here was a cool idea but the slidershapes themselves are so discoordinated I wish I could patch this up without giving me a headache :(
this map makes me kinda angry because i really love so many of the ideas here i just wish there was more effort put into making the map interesting to play through and not just look at
was positively surprised by this, was expecting a borefest because i never really thought this song would make for an immersive map but it's pretty good overall
it's hard to say anything about this map without any bias because of how (im)popular it's gotten in here at some points, but i feel like in my years of osu!, few maps managed to catch my attention like this one regarding how accessible and well-constructed it manages to be at the same time. some parts can definitely feel a bit rough to play but it's still noteworthy how creative and fun a map can be while taking on an apparently tough song to try and map.
the only big problem i could find about this map is that once everyone starts talking about how good it is, it gets old fast and maybe that's why it can be divisive for some people. but every once in a while i have to either check it in the editor or play it to remind myself of its qualities
+
some good ideas. the overall aesthetic and the movement in parts like 01:15:821 (1) - give quite a bit of personality to this, definitely prefer this rather than someone making a flow aim farm mapset to cash in on the current meta. the parts where you use contrast and difficulty progression through a section are also quite enjoyable
-
i don't really feel like cs5 fits too much with the general purpose of the map in a playability sense, but that's a minor complaint. i don't really get some of the rhythm inconsistencies like 00:25:367 (1,2,3) - / 01:07:912 (4,1) - , feels deliberate but at the same time the purpose isn't too identifiable. stuff like 00:36:548 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1) - looks cool in the editor, but as a player it really plays so umcomfortably, kinda wish you kept a constant linear movement with these as you did with the sliders but i do get your idea. 02:51:276 (1) - the ending here isn't exactly BAD but it feels completely out of place in this map, having one single huge jump aim diffspike at the end seems really questionable to me especially when the song really doesn't showcase anything too different
song carry but dont care
WHATG
i wish i managed to rank this one
i feel like this is one of those maps i'm going to appreciate more in the future but i still recognize the stupid amount of effort i put into trying to make this work
probably a more consistent package than dot in the sky but i feel like it lacks something compared to the other map
i think the first half is definitely a bit more bland but i feel it's a necessary contrast to make it stand out a bit more
surprised at how this one blew up
more fun than i probably intended it to be
i'm kinda proud of this one actually
OK I had a vision there it was just really blurred
I feel like the concept here was a cool idea but the slidershapes themselves are so discoordinated I wish I could patch this up without giving me a headache :(
Boring than boring...
this map makes me kinda angry because i really love so many of the ideas here i just wish there was more effort put into making the map interesting to play through and not just look at
I finally get it
would be a good map but sadly galvenize did this 12 years ago when he mapped gold dust
was positively surprised by this, was expecting a borefest because i never really thought this song would make for an immersive map but it's pretty good overall
02:56:084 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - love this
shoutouts to 01:03:243 (1) - being cool but I think this goes way too far
i enjoy it when funny slider maps actually try and make it enjoyable for the player to hit the sliders so this is good
it's hard to say anything about this map without any bias because of how (im)popular it's gotten in here at some points, but i feel like in my years of osu!, few maps managed to catch my attention like this one regarding how accessible and well-constructed it manages to be at the same time. some parts can definitely feel a bit rough to play but it's still noteworthy how creative and fun a map can be while taking on an apparently tough song to try and map.
the only big problem i could find about this map is that once everyone starts talking about how good it is, it gets old fast and maybe that's why it can be divisive for some people. but every once in a while i have to either check it in the editor or play it to remind myself of its qualities
i think this might be the absolute limit you can push a mapping style that is literally from 2005 and it pays off big
im just glad more people are mapping this kind of song
it's bland but at least does bland right. it could be nino's version which really did not age well in that regard
aistre's diff is if hollow wings, angelhoney and ignorethis had a love child and the child grew up to be a crack addict who lives in the streets
+
some good ideas. the overall aesthetic and the movement in parts like 01:15:821 (1) - give quite a bit of personality to this, definitely prefer this rather than someone making a flow aim farm mapset to cash in on the current meta. the parts where you use contrast and difficulty progression through a section are also quite enjoyable
-
i don't really feel like cs5 fits too much with the general purpose of the map in a playability sense, but that's a minor complaint. i don't really get some of the rhythm inconsistencies like 00:25:367 (1,2,3) - / 01:07:912 (4,1) - , feels deliberate but at the same time the purpose isn't too identifiable. stuff like 00:36:548 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1) - looks cool in the editor, but as a player it really plays so umcomfortably, kinda wish you kept a constant linear movement with these as you did with the sliders but i do get your idea. 02:51:276 (1) - the ending here isn't exactly BAD but it feels completely out of place in this map, having one single huge jump aim diffspike at the end seems really questionable to me especially when the song really doesn't showcase anything too different
-0.5 because of the weird cutstream at the end