1-2 jumps
denied| Name | 1-2 jumps |
| Description | Utilises jump patterning which is comboed into pairs during key moments of a map, typically with sharp aim intended for comfortable gameplay. It's strongly associated with continuous 1/2 kick-snare drums. |
| Parent descriptor | jump aim |
| Usable | True |
| Proposer | moonpoint |
| Type | new |
| Creation date | 2024-01-13 12:56:10 |
| Last updated | 2024-01-20 22:06:30 |
| Proposals can be approved when it receives 20 votes and has >=65% positive votes. Approvals can only happen after a minimum of 5 days. | |
| Status | denied by moonpoint |
Vote
37.5% voted positivelyyes (12): moonpoint, -Koish-, rdsdsk2, Boombox, a cat, aspen, geiboi77, maxb, Evamare, gwb, Kurboh, Sanch-KK
no (16): startone, choke enough, chorath, Oolt cloud, Fsjallink, MonsieurSebas, [[[[[[, Erikillo, App, ayel, Deca, fluxie31, Lytian, Mizunashi Akari, momothx, 222222222222222
hold (4): yukic, KnightC0re, milr_
Comments (14)
Comments are disabled for proposals with an outcome.
Comments are disabled for proposals with an outcome.
this goes hard
I don't see how the comboing of some jumps in a part of the map warrants a category, considering I wouldn't say it tells you essentially anything about the map at all, it would be as useful as if 1234 streams were a category.
as much as i dislike having a descriptor like that, there's nothing wrong with, so yea
hold no yes no yes no yes no yes no yes no yes
yes no yes no yes no yes no yes no yes no hold
yeah okay
Mirroring some key bullet points discord conversation about this with sebas:
- This is not really intended to be exclusive to farm maps. Maps like olc's ROBOT STOP definitely could use this descriptor since it uses 1-2 jumps quite prominently in one of it's sections
- It'd be good to have a wider range of descriptors to choose from so that we can more accurately describe entire styles. Think back to the "russian-style" descriptor proposal: one of the take-aways from that was that it'd be good to describe maps that are "russian-style" with more granular terms that'd together describe the maps better.
- For example a key part of the "sotarks-like" style, that mappers like Reform and SMOKELIND used to rely on heavily, definitely are 1-2 jumps. It's a pretty distinguishable part of that particular style.
- Yes the term has a connotation for farm maps because Sotarks spawned the term, but I don't see that as a problem. If anything, that reinforces the term's history as a source.
- I'm not happy at all with the idea of a "farm map" descriptor, because the way I see it that's then dependent on the state of the pp & SR system, and who knows how that'll look like a year or 5 or 10 from now.
Lets be real here, this term has connotations; no one is gonna call kami no kotoba a 1-2 jump map even though it has a lot of them.
So why not just say farm map at that point? And i also dont think tagging maps as "1-2 jumps" means much, Liek it doesnt tell me jack about the maps overall style, just what it has in the last 10 seconds of a chorus so i dont think its a good descriptor
i kinda think this is a bit similar to sharp aim descriptor
though i did had a thought when playing through a lot of maps that "comfortable aim" might also be a good new descriptor, cus i feel that there are jumps with wider angles that are still comfortable, though i didn't go through with proposing since it still has similarities to existing descriptors and a bit too subjective
@-Koish- NCing is absolutely 100% the name-sake of 1-2 jumps
@AJT hence the "typically" clause. either way awkwardness is subjective, and if u see a map with both 1-2 jumps and wide aim descriptors then that should be enough to derive how the 1-2 jumps are likely being used
i think the name is fine
tbh yes
uhhh ncing not necessary?
Sorta speaks for itself; I think this would be extremely beneficial for discovery and categorization of a particular type of farm map.